Money talks, but voters weren’t listening 

Graphic by Ilse von Heimburg / North by Northwestern.

There is a common adage in American politics: Money is power. And for good reason. Campaign spending has long been one of the most contentious issues in American elections, shaping debates over political influence, wealthy donors, Super PACs, and the laws governing campaign finance.

The assumption that candidates who raise more money have a largely improved chance of winning is relatively straightforward. 

But last week’s midterm elections raise a more complicated question: How much does money actually matter when it runs up against a controversial political environment, specifically one consisting of record-low presidential approval ratings? 

This year’s elections offered a particularly interesting test of that question. Despite an unprecedented influx of money into congressional races, Republicans suffered significant losses, with Democrats gaining control of both chambers of Congress in a convincing fashion. In several pivotal Senate contests, Republican-aligned super PACs spent substantially more than their Democratic counterparts, yet their financial advantages did not translate into victories. Even gubernatorial races had the same outcome, where Republican Greg Abott of Texas lost to Democrat Gina Hinojosa by nearly a million votes, despite raising six times more than Hinojosa. 

First we must look at the mechanics of campaign spending. The common understanding is that more money increases a candidate’s ability to reach voters, whether through advertisements, social media campaigns, or alternative mediums. Money pays for ads, digital outreach, campaign staff, voter mobilization, and the infrastructure necessary to compete in increasingly expensive elections. A well-funded campaign can maintain a presence in the public conversation and respond to attacks from opponents. However, with the huge influx of cheaper ways to reach voters, whether this be the use of artificial intelligence or social media, this idea does not hold up as well as it has in past decades. 

For the 2026 midterms, financial disclosures show that the top 20 donors collectively contributed roughly $2 billion to federal races through the most recent filing deadline in mid-October. The list reflects the growing influence of wealthy individuals and organizations willing to spend enormous sums to shape the political landscape.

Elon Musk, for example, emerged as the largest individual political donor of the cycle, contributing hundreds of millions of dollars, almost exclusively to Republican-aligned groups. Other wealthy donors on both sides of the political aisle also directed substantial resources toward influencing congressional races. 

Yet, the election results complicate the assumption that more money necessarily means more political success.

According to Reuters, Republican-aligned outside groups raised almost double than Democratic-aligned groups in Senate races this cycle, an estimated $1.1 billion dollars to Democrats’ $667 million dollars, respectively. Republicans nevertheless lost at least eight seats, with more than $1 billion spent on races that they ultimately lost. 

These patterns of spending are clear in Ohio and Michigan, where Republican-backed groups consistently outspent their Democratic counterparts, and still lost the senate race.

These outcomes raise an important distinction between the ability to finance a campaign and the ability to persuade voters.

But money cannot guarantee that voters will agree with a candidate’s message. It cannot change their perceptions of the economy, their dissatisfaction with the party in power, or their broader assessment of the country’s direction.

That distinction may help explain the Republican losses this November. The results were not simply a reflection of individual Senate campaigns or their respective fundraising operations. They unfolded within a broader national environment characterized by voter dissatisfaction with the Trump administration, concerns about the cost of living, and frustration with the direction of the country. The Associated Press reported that these issues were among the factors driving Democratic gains.

In other words, individual campaigns were operating within a political climate that they could not entirely control.

This raises the question of whether fundraising advantages matter as much when the national environment is already moving decisively in one direction. If voters are dissatisfied with the party in power, can millions of dollars in advertisements and outside spending meaningfully change their minds? Or does that money simply reinforce messages that voters have already decided whether to accept?

There is also a distinction worth examining between money raised directly by candidates and money spent by outside organizations. Super PACs can accept unlimited contributions and spend enormous sums independently of the campaigns they support. But their ability to flood a race with advertisements does not necessarily mean they have the same connection to voters as the candidates themselves.

Last week’s results illustrate this complication. In several competitive Senate races, Republican candidates benefited from substantial outside spending advantages, while Democratic candidates demonstrated considerable strength in direct fundraising. In Texas, Democrat James Talarico’s campaign raised more than $145 million directly, while Republican Ken Paxton’s campaign raised considerably less and relied heavily on outside support (partially because of how unfavorable Paxton was viewed as a candidate). 

This does not prove that direct fundraising is inherently more effective than outside spending. Nor does it mean that wealthy donors have lost their influence. Rather, it suggests that the source and use of campaign money deserve as much attention as the total amount spent.

The implications extend beyond this election cycle. For years, campaign finance reform advocates have argued that the growing influence of wealthy donors threatens the principle of equal political participation. The Supreme Court’s 2010 decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission helped establish the legal framework allowing corporations, unions, and individuals to make unlimited independent political expenditures. Since then, outside spending has become an increasingly prominent feature of federal elections, with total spending for the 2026 midterms reaching almost $12 billion dollars. 

Citizens United still serves as an extremely troublesome legal precedent – and this election does not take away from that. However, it does go to show how national politics, and the underlying political atmosphere, is able to undermine the will of some elite donors. 

Even if money failed to deliver the victories some donors sought, the concentration of political contributions among a relatively small number of wealthy individuals remains an important question about the role of money in American democracy. Financial influence can shape which candidates receive support, which issues receive attention, and how much political advertising voters encounter.

At the same time, this election demonstrates that financial resources are not the only determinant of political outcomes. Wealthy donors can help candidates compete, but they cannot purchase public approval or guarantee that voters will embrace their preferred candidates.

Perhaps the most important lesson from 2026 is not that money no longer matters in politics. It is that money has limits. Fundraising advantages may help campaigns capitalize on favorable political conditions, but they are not necessarily enough to overcome unfavorable ones.

Money may buy advertisements, campaign infrastructure, and access to voters. What it cannot always buy is their support.

And in a democracy, that distinction still matters.